Trust in the Workplace: Building Trust Between Coworkers

Trust is one of those words that gets thrown around in the workplace like collaboration, transparency and open communication. Everybody says it's important. It's probably in your organization's core values. There's likely a PowerPoint about it somewhere.

But here's the thing about trust. It takes time to build, sometimes years. You build it by showing up, following through, having difficult conversations, keeping confidences and doing what you said you were going to do.

And then one day, someone shares something they shouldn't, throws you under the bus in a meeting or makes a decision behind your back that you find out about from someone three departments over.

And just like that, you're sitting there thinking, Well, that's good to know.

Congratulations. We've entered the part of the working relationship where I'm suddenly very careful about what I say in front of you.

It's Usually the Little Things That Add Up

We tend to think of broken trust as some big, dramatic betrayal. And sometimes it is. But more often, it's a collection of smaller moments that slowly change how you see someone.

It's the conversation you thought was confidential that somehow makes its way around the office. The coworker who agrees with you privately but suddenly has a completely different opinion when leadership joins the meeting. The supervisor who tells you they'll support a decision and then leaves you standing alone when someone questions it.

One incident might be a misunderstanding. Two might be a coincidence. But eventually, patterns start to emerge, and you realize you're spending more time trying to figure out who you can trust than actually doing your job.

And that's exhausting.

Trust isn't built by saying, “You can trust me.” It's built when your actions consistently give people a reason to believe it. Because people remember who showed up, who followed through and who conveniently developed amnesia when things got uncomfortable.

When Trust Leaves, Everything Gets Harder

Here's what happens when trust starts disappearing in a workplace. People stop speaking freely. They start documenting conversations that used to require nothing more than a quick phone call. They copy additional people on emails, not because those people need the information, but because everybody suddenly needs a witness.

Meetings become less about solving problems and more about making sure nobody gets blamed for one. People hesitate to share ideas, admit mistakes or ask questions because they're not sure how that information might be used later.

And the really frustrating part? The actual work doesn't go away. Now you're just trying to get it done while navigating office politics, second-guessing motives and wondering whether that innocent-looking email is about to become Exhibit A.

A workplace without trust doesn't necessarily look chaotic from the outside. Sometimes everybody is polite, meetings run on time and people say all the right things. But underneath all that professionalism, nobody feels comfortable being completely honest.

That's not collaboration. That's self-preservation with an Outlook calendar.

Rebuilding Trust Takes More Than an Apology

I believe people make mistakes. I've made plenty myself, and I certainly wouldn't want every poor decision I've ever made to define me forever. Sometimes trust is damaged because of miscommunication, competing priorities or someone handling a situation badly rather than intentionally trying to hurt anyone.

But rebuilding trust requires more than saying, “I'm sorry you feel that way,” and expecting everyone to move on by Friday.

It requires acknowledging what happened, taking responsibility and being willing to have the uncomfortable conversation. More importantly, it requires changing the behavior that damaged the relationship in the first place.

And here's the part that can be difficult for leaders: you don't get to decide when someone else trusts you again. You can apologize, explain your intentions and work to make things right, but the other person gets to decide whether your actions have earned that trust back.

Sometimes relationships recover. Sometimes they become stronger because people finally address what wasn't working. And sometimes the relationship remains professional, but it never quite returns to what it was before.

That's not necessarily holding a grudge. Sometimes it's just remembering what happened and adjusting accordingly.

The Bottom Line

Trust is one of the most valuable things you can build in a workplace, and one of the easiest things to take for granted. It makes difficult conversations easier, teamwork stronger and leadership a whole lot less exhausting.

But once it's damaged, everything becomes more complicated. People become guarded, communication changes and relationships that once felt easy suddenly require a lot more effort.

So if you're in a position of leadership, remember that people are paying attention to more than what you say. They're watching what you do, especially when it's inconvenient, uncomfortable or nobody important is in the room.

And if you've ever lost trust in someone at work, you know there's a big difference between being able to work with someone and actually trusting them.

You can still be polite. You can still be professional. You can even smile through the entire meeting.

But that doesn't mean you're ever telling them anything you wouldn't want forwarded to the entire leadership team again.

Contact

Email - hello@barelymanageable.com

© 2025. All rights reserved.